Dungeons & Dragons 4th Edition Gripes (Redux)
Recently Mike Mearls did a retrospective on why D&D 4th Edition failed.
It's been over a decade since I played and ran 4th Edition ("4E") D&D, but the question of what was wrong with it still keeps coming up on occasion, and my answers to the issue are spread across various places on the internet. So this is a more unified list of my complaints, or those I can sympathize with, that have been made over the years.
First, to be clear: I think for some people, 4th Edition was exactly the sort of game they were interested in. It did try to "balance" combat with principles like:
- Player characters each contribute approximately an equal amount to helping.
- Player characters are approximately on equal power with each other at each character level.
- Combats have a specific, predictable level of difficulty.
- Character classes are designed around specific categories of combat effectiveness (i.e. roles like "striker" or "controller"). These categories are relatively independent from the source of the character's powers.
- There are a certain number of combats per day, with power usages refreshing at specific intervals.
None of this was completely bad. And to some extent the previous edition had been trying to do some of this already. But the degree to which 4E pushed these principles, and the different type of rules mechanics involved in doing so, was a departure from the aspects of earlier editions which many had come to enjoy. Some folks have said it was too "videogamey", and certainly it did seem to use some team-videogame concepts, though I wouldn't say that was exactly what rubbed me the wrong way.
I ran a 4E game for maybe 6 months or more at the insistence of a local group, and participated as a player afterward for a few more months.
Prior to going into the experience, my main gripe was heavier reliance on "dissociated mechanics". This post explains an feeling that some of us were having at the time, but which we couldn't clearly articulate prior to reading it.
D&D 4th Edition also leaned heavily into the concept of "combat as sport", while a number of old school enthusiasts preferred "combat as war" (see discussion).
Certainly a lot of the powers and tools made explicitly available to characters in 4E were more exclusively geared toward combat than in previous editions.
But even a more rigidly defined tactical (less open-ended or improvisational) game had some slight appeal to me. So, setting all my issues with "dissociated" rules aside, I tried to enjoy it as a combat intensive game. Unfortunately, even in combat alone, 4th Ed. just had too many bits that stuck in my craw:
- Geared to win - Most combats it never felt like the characters were in much danger of dying. There was only one I can remember early on that was really a "close thing".
- Slog Combats - Despite not straining the characters much, a standard combat would usually take the majority of the evening, even against relatively weak opponents. This might partly have been an issue of people not having all their powers perfectly memorized and planned, but in some cases it was just a hassle of hit/miss whittling down a massive pile of opponent hit points every time. In general we would get into one combat per session, and it would take up most of the session.
- Level Wiff Factor - If average combats didn't seem much challenge, then combats against high level opponents were an exercise in missing and missing again. Unlike previous editions, 4th Edition, armor class escalates right along with everything else. So enemies of different levels are extremely difficult to hit.
- Equipment Wiff Factor - A couple of us realized late in the game that, unlike previous editions, expected PC equipment bonuses are heavily factored into the challenge rating of monsters. To the extent that the GM is literally required to keep providing you with equipment appropriate to your level. If you don't have the equipment power level mandated by your character level, you will miss a heck of a lot more.
- Character Optimization - I'd been given to understand that it would be difficult in 4E to make an ineffective character. But at one point I created a Dwarf melee Fighter of relatively average abilities. I tried to use my At Will and Encounter powers to good effect, but still found myself stumbling around widely spread battlefields only occasionally nickeling and diming opponents to little effect while my comrades laid into them with various ranged or heavy damage attacks (the Rogue especially figured out early on how to optimize his attacks and would just slaughter opponents in short order). As fighter it was very hard to get hurt badly, but I still didn't feel very effective.
And, if you weren't into such a strictly power-specific form of tactical play, then other options to resolve scenarios weren't particularly obvious from a player perspective. Very early on in the game, before they got basic mastery of the rules, I remember my players came up with a clever plan to blow up a kobold den by collecting materials to build an improvised black powder bomb. But once they figured out how effective their combat abilities were, they just waltzed into every dangerous-looking situation and started clobbering everything in sight. And, I could have tried to come up with more challenges that combat couldn't solve, but with so much of their chosen talents directed to tactical combat, it would be kind of denying them the opportunity to shine.
Aside from these insights from actual play, a few other things that bothered me and others included:
Since powers, equipment, and other mechanics worked a lot different than in previous editions, conversion of old material to the new system was less straightforward than in any previous case.
Additionally the license to reuse gaming material under 4th edition was much more restrictive than the Open Gaming License (OGL) allowed under 3rd Edition. This basically strangled the production of any third party products and made other creators feel relatively unwelcome to contribute. (With 5th Edition it seemed like they learned their lesson when they switched back to the OGL. But a few years later they would try to change the OGL to restrict creators again, causing a massive uproar.)
Also: I personally loved in old editions the existence of odd, quirky, or non-combat focused magical spells and tools. Things that hinted that magic wasn't just about blasting baddies, but had other random uses as well. But although there were a few non-combat powers and rituals, these types of things were less prominent or diverse than in previous editions.
Comments
Post a Comment
Due to continuing spam, there's now a delay for moderation.
Sorry. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯